DM’s note: This post is broken into two parts. Part I deals with general adventure writing ideas, and Part II focuses more on GenAI tools. If you’re just here for the AI, feel free to skip directly to Part II.
Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (D&D 5e) maintains its position as a leading tabletop role-playing game, captivating a global audience with its blend of collaborative storytelling and strategic gameplay. Concurrently, the landscape of creative industries is undergoing a significant transformation with the increasing sophistication and adoption of Generative AI (GenAI) tools. This technological advancement presents new possibilities for content creation across various domains. Consequently, a notable intersection has emerged between these two dynamic trends, with D&D enthusiasts and creators beginning to explore how GenAI can be leveraged to enhance the intricate process of writing adventure modules for the game. This report aims to dissect the established workflow for crafting D&D 5e adventures and to analyze the potential points of integration for these emerging GenAI creative tools.
Deconstructing the D&D 5e Adventure Module Writing Process
Creating a compelling and engaging adventure module for D&D 5e is a multifaceted process that typically involves several key stages. Understanding these steps is crucial for identifying where GenAI tools can offer meaningful assistance.
Brainstorming and Concept Development
The genesis of any D&D adventure lies in the initial brainstorming and concept development phase. Inspiration for these foundational ideas can stem from a wide array of sources, including existing literature, cinematic works, mythological narratives, historical events, or even beloved D&D adventures from the past 1. Creators often find themselves drawn to specific themes, evocative settings, or compelling narratives that resonate with their own creative interests and the preferences of their intended player group 1.
A critical element during this stage is the development of an adventure idea that presents an immediate and compelling problem, one that demands action and engagement from the player characters 2. For instance, an adventure that starts with the player characters finding themselves in a tavern engulfed in flames inherently creates a sense of urgency and necessitates immediate action. This contrasts with less compelling scenarios, such as a mundane task like guarding a merchant caravan, which may not evoke the same level of immediate player investment 2. The core concept needs to establish stakes that encourage players to utilize their heroic skills and make decisive choices.
The process of generating these initial ideas is often iterative and benefits from exploring diverse inputs. Drawing inspiration from various forms of media and analyzing the elements that made past adventures successful can spark new and unique concepts for a module. The scope of the intended adventure is another important consideration at this early stage. Will it be a concise one-shot session designed for a single play experience, or will it be a more expansive campaign intended to unfold over multiple sessions 1? Defining this scope helps to frame the scale of the narrative and the level of detail required in the subsequent stages of development.
The emphasis on an “urgent problem” as the foundation of a good adventure suggests that the initial concept must immediately capture the players’ attention and provide a clear motivation for their involvement. This initial hook is paramount for ensuring a compelling and enjoyable experience. Because creativity often flourishes through the combination of diverse elements, exploring a wide range of inspirational sources at the outset can lead to more innovative and engaging adventure concepts.
Narrative Design and Quest Development
Once a foundational concept is in place, the next step involves crafting the overarching storyline that will guide the adventure. This includes outlining the major plot points and the pivotal events that will drive the narrative forward 1. A useful approach to establishing this framework is to focus on three key elements: clearly defining the villains or antagonists, understanding their underlying goals and motivations, and outlining the specific actions they are taking to achieve those goals 3. This approach shifts the focus from a rigid, predetermined storyline to a dynamic situation in which the players can actively participate and influence the outcome.
The main narrative is then typically broken down into smaller, more manageable quests or story arcs, each with clearly defined objectives that the players can understand and pursue. These quests should also present obstacles that the players must overcome and offer potential rewards for their successful completion 1. To draw players into these quests, compelling quest hooks are essential. These hooks can be presented through various means, such as interactions with non-Player Characters (NPCs), the discovery of intriguing rumors, or the uncovering of significant clues 1.
Allowing for player agency is a crucial aspect of modern adventure design. Incorporating branching paths and meaningful choices within the narrative empowers players to feel that their decisions have a real impact on the unfolding events, leading to different outcomes and adding depth to the module 1. Furthermore, the pacing of the adventure should be carefully considered to build excitement and tension as the story progresses, culminating in well-designed climactic moments that provide a sense of resolution or set the stage for future developments 1.
For more intricate adventures, developing multiple interconnected plots with varying levels of stakes can add significant depth and complexity. These plots can incorporate elements of mystery, time-sensitive challenges that increase tension, and surprising plot twists that keep players engaged 5. This layered approach can create a richer and more believable game world where different threads of the narrative intertwine.
The shift from a strictly linear “storyline” to establishing a dynamic “situation” emphasizes a player-centric design philosophy. By focusing on the initial setup of villains, their motivations, and their actions, the Dungeon Master (DM) creates a framework within which players have the freedom to shape the narrative through their choices and interactions. The inclusion of interconnected plots and unexpected twists reflects a desire to craft adventures that are not only engaging but also full of surprises, ensuring a memorable experience for the players.
Developing Locations and Encounters
With the narrative framework in place, the next stage involves bringing the adventure to life by developing the key locations where the story will unfold. This requires visualizing and describing these spaces with attention to detail, focusing on their unique characteristics, atmosphere, and any sensory details that can immerse the players in the setting 1. Whether it’s a foreboding dungeon, a bustling town, or a mystical forest, each location should feel distinct and contribute to the overall tone of the adventure.
Creating maps of these significant locations is also a crucial step. These maps, which can range from simple sketches to detailed drawings, help players visualize the environment and understand the spatial relationships between different areas. Important features such as entrances, exits, points of interest, and potential hiding spots should be clearly marked 1. Digital tools like Inkarnate and DungeonDraft can be invaluable resources for creating professional-looking maps, even for those who may not have extensive artistic skills 4.
Once the locations are established, the next step is to populate them with a variety of encounters and challenges that will test the players’ skills and advance the story. These encounters can take many forms, including combat situations, intriguing puzzles, treacherous traps, engaging social interactions with NPCs, and opportunities for exploration 1. Designing engaging combat encounters requires careful consideration of monster variety, the tactical approaches the monsters might employ, and the terrain in which the fight takes place 4.
Balancing the difficulty of these encounters is paramount to ensure a satisfying experience for the players. The Challenge Rating (CR) system provides a guideline for determining the appropriate level of threat based on the player characters’ levels 3. Effective encounter design often incorporates elements of enticement to draw the players in, pressure to maintain momentum, opportunities for interaction with the environment or the adversaries, and meaningful consequences based on the players’ actions 6. Furthermore, interesting locations often feature special terrain, unique objects, or intriguing gimmicks that can be integrated with the adventure’s narrative, making the environment itself a dynamic element of the gameplay 11.
The emphasis on vivid descriptions and detailed maps underscores the importance of strong worldbuilding in creating immersive and engaging adventures. These visual and descriptive elements help players to feel present in the game world and to make informed decisions. The detailed guidance on designing combat encounters highlights the complexity involved in creating balanced and challenging situations that go beyond simply pitting players against a series of monsters. Thoughtful consideration of monster tactics, environmental factors, and the overall flow of combat is essential for creating truly engaging encounters.
Creating NPCs and Monsters
A crucial aspect of any D&D adventure is the creation of compelling non-Player Characters (NPCs) and formidable monsters. NPCs serve as the primary means through which players interact with the game world, providing information, offering quests, and driving the narrative forward. Developing a diverse cast of memorable NPCs requires crafting intriguing backstories, defining their motivations, and giving them distinct personalities 1. Giving NPCs unique goals and memorable quirks can make them more engaging and help them stand out in the players’ minds 1. Well-developed NPCs should feel like three-dimensional characters with their own desires, secrets, and histories 18.
Among the NPCs, villains play a particularly important role in shaping the adventure’s central conflict. Designing compelling villains requires more than simply creating an antagonist to be defeated. Effective villains have clear goals, understandable motivations, and well-developed backstories that explain their actions 3. They should feel like more than just obstacles, possessing depth and complexity that can challenge the players on multiple levels.
The monsters that inhabit the adventure world also require careful consideration. They should be thematically appropriate for the setting and the overall narrative 3. Exploring the lore associated with different monsters can provide inspiration for their behavior and their role in the adventure. Incorporating a variety of monster types within combat encounters can lead to more dynamic and engaging challenges, requiring players to adapt their strategies 7. Furthermore, designing monsters with unique mechanics that go beyond standard attacks and hit points can surprise players and create more memorable encounters 26.
The emphasis on creating memorable NPCs and villains highlights the critical role that compelling characters play in engaging players and driving the narrative. Players are more likely to connect with an adventure if they encounter interesting and well-developed individuals. Similarly, the advice on tailoring monsters to the adventure’s theme and incorporating unique mechanics underscores the importance of creativity and originality in encounter design. Moving beyond standard monster stat blocks to create adversaries with distinct abilities and behaviors can lead to more exciting and memorable gameplay experiences.
Incorporating Treasure and Rewards
Rewards are an integral part of the D&D experience, providing players with a sense of accomplishment and contributing to their characters’ progression. These rewards can take various forms, including traditional treasures like gold and magical items, as well as more intangible benefits such as valuable information 1. The types and number of rewards should be carefully balanced based on the difficulty of the challenges the players face and their current character levels 1. Ensuring that the rewards feel meaningful and contribute to the ongoing story or the characters’ growth is also important 1.
The placement of treasure within the adventure can significantly impact player engagement. Instead of concentrating all the loot in one location, strategically distributing it throughout different areas encourages thorough exploration and rewards players for interacting with the entire module 3. Treasure can also serve as a plot device, advancing the narrative or leading to further adventures through clues, maps, or cursed items 28.
Beyond material wealth, non-monetary rewards can be particularly impactful. These can include appointments to positions of authority, decorations for exemplary service, access to special services, valuable contacts within the community, or even prestigious titles 29. These types of rewards can enhance the players’ sense of belonging within the game world and provide unique opportunities for roleplaying and further interaction.
When it comes to magical items, careful consideration should be given to their distribution to avoid imbalances within the party 30. Introducing upgradeable magic items or allowing players to enhance their existing gear can provide a sense of long-term progression without overwhelming them with too many powerful artifacts 30.
The advice on strategically placing treasure and incorporating non-monetary rewards suggests a move towards a more holistic approach to rewarding players. Meaningful rewards should go beyond simply providing mechanical advantages and instead enhance the players’ connection to the story and the game world. The considerations around balancing magic items and exploring upgradeable options reflect the ongoing challenge of providing satisfying rewards that maintain the game’s balance and longevity.
Playtesting and Refinement
Once a draft of the adventure module is complete, playtesting becomes an essential step in the development process. Running the adventure with a group of players allows the creator to identify any potential issues, such as unclear instructions, unbalanced encounters, or plot inconsistencies 1. Observing how players interact with the content, approach challenges, and make decisions provides invaluable feedback that can be used to fine-tune the overall gameplay experience 1.
Gathering feedback directly from the playtesters is crucial. Asking specific questions about their experience, noting areas of confusion or difficulty, and understanding what aspects of the adventure they enjoyed most will help the creator identify areas that need improvement 1. The refinement process is often iterative, involving revisions and adjustments based on the feedback received. This may involve tweaking encounter balance, clarifying quest objectives, enhancing location descriptions, or even making changes to the overall narrative structure 1.
Playtesting is highlighted as a critical step because it provides an external perspective on the adventure. The creator, being deeply involved in the design process, may overlook issues that become apparent to someone experiencing the module for the first time. This feedback loop is essential for ensuring that the final adventure is engaging, balanced, and enjoyable for a wider audience.
Formatting and Presentation
The final stage of the adventure module writing process involves formatting and presenting the content in a clear and organized manner. Using clear headings, subheadings, and bullet points can significantly improve readability and make it easier for other DMs to understand and run the adventure 1. Including all necessary maps, handouts for the players, and stat blocks for monsters and NPCs is also essential for providing a complete and user-friendly module 1. Consistent formatting throughout the document helps to create a professional and polished final product.
Sources
1. How to Write a DnD Module (From Actual DMs) – Epochscapes, accessed March 15, 2025, https://epochscapes.com/resources/dungeons-and-dragons/homebrew/how-to-write-a-dnd-module/
2. How to Write A D&D Adventure: The Complete Guide – The Arcane …, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.thearcanelibrary.com/blogs/news/how-to-write-a-d-d-adventure-the-complete-guide
3. How to Make a D&D Adventure in 10 Steps – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/how-to-make-a-d-d-adventure-in-10-steps
4. How to Write a Good D&D 5e Adventure – DMDave Publishing, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dmdave.com/good-dd-5e-adventure/
5. How I Write Adventures, A Short Explanatory Guide : r/DMAcademy, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DMAcademy/comments/83zl5y/how_i_write_adventures_a_short_explanatory_guide/
6. How To Design Exciting D&D Encounters – The Arcane Library, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.thearcanelibrary.com/blogs/news/how-to-write-excellent-d-d-encounters
7. dnd 5e 2014 – How can I make combat more tactically interesting for …, accessed March 15, 2025, https://rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/69528/how-can-i-make-combat-more-tactically-interesting-for-me-as-a-dm
8. Designing Encounters | Level Up – A5E.tools, accessed March 15, 2025, https://a5e.tools/rules/designing-encounters
9. Designing Unforgettable Combat Encounters for RPGs, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.hipstersanddragons.com/designing-combat-encounters-advice/
10. How to make combat more engaging and fun? : r/dndnext – Reddit, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/dndnext/comments/pmunm1/how_to_make_combat_more_engaging_and_fun/
11. 10 Pro Tips for Designing a D&D Adventure – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/10-pro-tips-for-designing-a-d-d-adventure
12. Creating and Preparing an Adventure for D&D | The DM’s Journey, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dmsjourney.com/creating-an-adventure/
13. Non-Playable Characters – 15 Tips For Making Memorable NPCs – The Alchemist Circle, accessed March 15, 2025, https://alchemistcircle.com/non-playable-characters-15-tips-for-making-memorable-npcs/
14. Crafting Memorable NPCs – Dungeon Master Academy, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dungeonmaster.academy/articles/crafting-memorable-npcs
15. 15 Tips for Creating Amazing NPCs in D&D – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/15-tips-for-creating-amazing-npcs-in-d-d
16. How to Create NPCs Your D&D Players Will Actually Care About …, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/how-to-create-npcs-your-d-d-players-will-actually-care-about
17. Four Steps to Create Amazing D&D NPCs in 60 seconds! – Eventyr Games, accessed March 15, 2025, https://eventyrgames.com/2022/01/04/create-amazing-dd-npcs-in-60-seconds/
18. How to Create an Engaging Story for Your D&D Game – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/how-to-create-an-engaging-story-for-your-d-d-game
19. How to Write a D&D Campaign: Tips for Engaging Storylines – Dice Bag, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dicebag.co.uk/blogs/the-scroll/how-to-write-a-d-d-campaign-tips-for-engaging-storylines
20. How do you write your adventures? – Dungeon Masters Only – D&D Beyond, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.dndbeyond.com/forums/dungeons-dragons-discussion/dungeon-masters-only/1707-how-do-you-write-your-adventures
21. D&D Villain – 7 Essential Tips for Creating a Remarkable Adversary, accessed March 15, 2025, https://beforeyouroll.com/unforgettable-dnd-villain/
22. Tips On How To Make A Villain Your Players Love To Hate In D&D, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.thegamer.com/dungeons-dragons-dnd-tips-make-villain-love-to-hate/
23. 5 Strategies for Creating Unforgettable Big Bad Villains | Gnome Stew, accessed March 15, 2025, https://gnomestew.com/5-strategies-for-creating-unforgettable-big-bad-villains/
24. Creating a Compelling Villain : r/DnDBehindTheScreen – Reddit, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/DnDBehindTheScreen/comments/a38dn7/creating_a_compelling_villain/
25. How to create good villains that will leave and everlasting mark on my players – Dungeon Masters Only – D&D Beyond, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.dndbeyond.com/forums/dungeons-dragons-discussion/dungeon-masters-only/182582-how-to-create-good-villains-that-will-leave-and
26. D&D Monster Design Lessons: 2cGaming’s Eyes that Bite – Illusory …, accessed March 15, 2025, https://illusoryscript.com/dnd-monster-design-eyes-that-bite/
27. How to Place Treasure and Loot in D&D – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/how-to-place-treasure-and-loot-in-d-d
28. D&D Ideas — Treasure – Nerdarchy, accessed March 15, 2025, https://nerdarchy.com/dd-ideas-treasure/
29. Advanced Rewards & Recognition System for D&D 5e – The DM Lair, accessed March 15, 2025, https://thedmlair.com/blogs/news/advanced-rewards-recognition-system-for-d-d-5e
30. Rewarding the PCs in 5E D&D – Eventyr Games, accessed March 15, 2025, https://eventyrgames.com/2022/08/23/rewarding-the-pcs-in-5e-dd/
31. The 7 Best AI Tools for DMs That Will Transform Your D&D Campaign, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.the-enchanted-scribe.com/post/the-7-best-ai-tools-for-dms-that-will-transform-your-d-d-campaign
32. Dungeon Master Tools | The Enchanted Scribe, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.the-enchanted-scribe.com/dungeon-master-tools
33. How to use AI as a Dungeon Master Tool – Modular Realms, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.modularrealms.com/blogs/news/dungeon-master-tools-how-can-ai-help-me-dm
34. 15 Amazing GenAI Tools to Try in 2024 – Acorn Labs, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.acorn.io/resources/learning-center/generative-ai-tools/
35. Saga: AI Text RPG, accessed March 15, 2025, https://sagarpg.io/
36. Mmorpg creation – There’s an AI For That®, accessed March 15, 2025, https://theresanaiforthat.com/s/mmorpg+creation/
37. AI Dungeon, accessed March 15, 2025, https://aidungeon.com/
38. Best AI RPG Generators and RPG AI Games 2023 – Inworld AI, accessed March 15, 2025, https://inworld.ai/blog/best-ai-rpg-generator-and-rpg-ai-games
39. RPG Prompts: AI-Powered RPG Adventures, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.rpgprompts.com/
40. AI Dungeon Master | AI-powered Dungeons & Dragons campaign creator and manager | HyperWrite AI Writing Assistant, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.hyperwriteai.com/aitools/ai-dungeon-master
41. AI DnD Generator – Hotpot.ai, accessed March 15, 2025, https://hotpot.ai/dnd-generator
42. DUNGEONFOG | Free RPG Battle map editor for D&D / Dungeonfog, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.dungeonfog.com/
43. How to Design World Maps for Sandbox Campaigns for DnD – Dungeon Goblin, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dungeongoblin.com/blog/how-to-design-sandbox-world-map
44. AI tools for GM : r/rpg – Reddit, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/1gb1qud/ai_tools_for_gm/
45. LoreKeeper | GenAI Works, accessed March 15, 2025, https://genai.works/applications/lorekeeper
46. Powerful Ways How AI Can Enhance Your D&D Sessions | by Dungeon Goblin, accessed March 15, 2025, https://dungeongoblin.medium.com/powerful-ways-how-ai-can-enhance-your-d-d-sessions-7c0d92af4ab9
47. The Best LLM for Generating RPG Stuff – Your Brain: SlyFlourish.com, accessed March 15, 2025, https://slyflourish.com/best_llm.html
48. An AI trained on Dungeons & Dragons – General Discussion – D&D Beyond, accessed March 15, 2025, https://www.dndbeyond.com/forums/d-d-beyond-general/general-discussion/214860-an-ai-trained-on-dungeons-dragons
AI Dungeon Master Tools 
Leave a comment